Loading …
Podcast Transformation Leadership Finance AI

The Business Case is a Lie: What a CFO Thinks About Your Transformation

  • November 17, 2026
  • By Sullivan & Stanley
  • 5 minute read

The 7 Percent, episode 4 | Host: Andy Haley, CEO of Sullivan & Stanley | Guest: Craig Vale, Finance Director, Club L London | Released 17th November 2026 | 30 minutes

🎧 Spotify | 🎧 Apple Podcasts | ▶️ YouTube

Many transformation business cases are written as sales pitches to win funding, so they leave out risks the business will later have to manage. That’s Andy Haley’s working hypothesis, and in episode four of The 7 Percent, Craig Vale largely agrees. Drawing on over 25 years in finance, from audit at Ernst & Young to running finance at Ryman and now as Finance Director at Club L London, Craig explains how he tests a business case before any money goes in, and how the role of the CFO in transformation is changing.

Key takeaways

  • Business cases are often written to win funding, so Craig Vale brings professional scepticism to find what’s been left out.

  • Craig tests every investment against the overall goal of the business, and checks it’s coordinated with the teams it depends on.

  • Craig works to a multi-year plan that’s reforecast often, with guardrails and checkpoints that catch drift before the budget is gone.

  • In a high-growth business, Craig measures the value of AI by what people do with the hours it saves, through revenue, margin, conversion and returns.

  • His advice to aspiring CFOs is to learn the language of every department and keep pace with technology.

How should a CFO assess a transformation business case?

Andy puts his hypothesis to Craig: business cases are often sales pitches written to secure funding. Craig largely agrees. Someone with an idea they believe in may not lay out every risk.

His tests start with whether the investment contributes to the overall goal of the business. Next is whether it’s coordinated with the teams it relies on. Craig describes his business as circular, because great product needs an e-commerce team to display it, a marketing team to talk about it and a merchandising team to buy it. After that, he weighs the risks against the rewards.

Craig credits his audit background for his habit of professional scepticism, which he has to work at because he’s an optimist by nature. He gives a recent example. Soon after joining, he inherited an ERP project that had run for over two years under people who had since left. After a couple of months reviewing it, he had it mothballed until after peak trading, because the business hadn’t yet settled what it wanted from it.

How is the CFO’s role in transformation changing?

As Finance Director at Club L London, Craig still has the traditional responsibilities: controls, processes and making sure there’s cash in the bank to pay the bills. Moving from turnaround into high growth has changed the question he asks most. In a cash-rich business with global ambitions, he worries less about paying suppliers and more about whether the business is moving fast enough to reach its goals.

In his first four months at Club L London, he started weekly updates where he stands up in front of the whole office and repeats the goal, what’s working and what isn’t. He admits it isn’t a traditional CFO role. For Craig, it’s how people come to understand their part in reaching the goal.

Should finance sign off multi-year transformation budgets?

Andy raises a common frustration for delivery teams: a transformation lasts several years, but its budget is only confirmed one year at a time. Craig’s answer is that both of his recent businesses work to a multi-year plan, currently a three-year view, which is reforecast continually as conditions change.

A large investment under that plan is assessed against the vision at 12, 24 and 36 months, and budget is allocated within that framework. The worst case is a project that has spent its budget six or 12 months in. Craig guards against it with diligence upfront, clear guardrails and checkpoints along the way. If a project starts to drift, he asks what the business will give up in return.

How should finance leaders measure the value of AI?

Craig calls himself people first, and says technology is there to support them. Club L London is the most technologically advanced business he’s worked in, with a dbt platform, a semantic layer and self-serve data that produces analysis in seconds. The people who used to produce that analysis are still there. Their job now is to turn insight into action.

That’s where the difference between turnaround and growth matters. In a turnaround, hours saved are hours saved, and that can lead to hard decisions. In high growth, the question becomes what else those people can do with the time. Craig looks for the value in faster revenue growth, better margin, higher conversion and lower returns rates.

How is AI changing relationships at the top table?

Craig sees an evolution in the boardroom. Some leaders defend their teams, while others focus on what the technology could replace. He believes a high-functioning board keeps a creative tension between the two and can discuss it openly without fear of reproach. He balances short-term cost savings against long-term value creation.

What advice does Craig give finance leaders stepping up to CFO?

At its simplest, Craig says the job of a CEO or CFO is to keep the business alive. In high growth, that means helping it grow. The traditional checks and balances still apply, but a modern CFO has to be far more operationally focused and speak the language of each department. His advice is direct: get off your desk, go and talk to people and understand the business. His own challenge is keeping pace with technology, because the rate of change can quickly leave a finance leader out of date.

About The 7 Percent

The 7 Percent is a podcast from Sullivan & Stanley, hosted by CEO Andy Haley. In each episode, Andy speaks with a senior leader who has been accountable for delivering major transformation about the decisions that shaped their programme. Season one runs to nine episodes, released fortnightly from 20th October 2026 to 2nd February 2027.

Listen to the previous episode: [Episode 3: Everyone says people come first in transformation. So why don't they?]